For many, the origins of the Jewish people might seem straightforward. After all, the word "Jew" derives from Yehudah – the ancient Hebrew name for the hill country around Jerusalem. Yet recently, this seemingly obvious connection has become a subject of debate, with some questioning whether modern Jews truly descend from the ancient inhabitants of Judea.
While these challenges often arise from political motives, particularly attempts to question Israel's legitimacy, they raise fascinating historical questions worth exploring. How do we actually know where the Jewish people come from? The answer illuminates not just Jewish history, but broader patterns of how ancient peoples migrated, how cultures survive across millennia, and how identity persists through exile and dispersion.
Our Jewish world
The modern Jewish story is one of concentration and dispersal. From a global population of about 15.7 million, over 85% of Jews now live in just two countries: Israel (7 million) and the United States (6 million). This represents a dramatic shift from a century ago when Jewish communities were scattered across Europe, North Africa, and the Middle East.
While smaller but significant Jewish communities flourish in France (440,000), Canada (390,000), Britain (290,000), and Argentina (175,000), other historic centers have dwindled. The former Soviet Union, once home to millions of Jews, now counts only 150,000, mostly in Russia and Ukraine. Yet even as ancient communities in places like Hungary and Morocco grow smaller, new Jewish populations are emerging in unexpected places like Germany and the United Arab Emirates.
Three transformative Jewish events
This remarkable concentration of Jewish life in Israel and the US resulted from three Jewish events, in chronological order, that changed everything. 1. The first began in the 1880s after waves of Eastern European Jews fled to America escaping persecution and poverty. The Kyiv pogrom of 1881, which left at least 40 Jews dead, exemplified the dangers they faced. This exodus transformed American Jewish life from just 300,000 Jews in 1880 (0.5% of the US population) the community grew tenfold to 3.6 million by 1920 (3% of the US population).
The second event was the Holocaust, history's darkest chapter. The Nazi genocide killed six million Jews – over 60% of European Jewry – reducing the global Jewish population from 16.5 million to 11 million. Many survivors, their European homes destroyed and families decimated, sought new lives in America and what would become Israel.
The third pivotal moment came with Israel's establishment, born from the 19th century's surge of nationalism. As new nations emerged across Europe – Greece (1832), Italy (1861), Germany (1871) – Jews faced a complex reality. While nationalism promised self-determination for distinct peoples sharing language, history, and traditions, Jews often found themselves excluded from these national movements. Inspired particularly by Greece's revival after centuries of foreign rule, Jewish thinkers developed Zionism, calling for restoring Jewish sovereignty in their ancestral homeland.
Reshaping the Middle East: The Birth of Modern Israel
The path to Israeli statehood began modestly in the late 19th century, as small groups of European Jews immigrated to Ottoman Palestine, purchasing and settling land alongside Jewish communities that had lived there for generations.
However, the real transformation came after World War I, when the victorious Allies began redrawing the world map. This era of nation-building saw the dissolution of old empires and the birth of new states, triggering massive population movements across Europe and the Middle East. The 1923 Treaty of Lausanne, for instance, orchestrated one of history's largest population exchanges: over 1.2 million Greeks left Turkey for Greece, while some 400,000 Muslims made the opposite journey. Similar exchanges reshaped the boundaries between Bulgaria and Turkey.
A new Middle East
The collapse of the Ottoman Empire led to the creation of several new states in the Middle East, each shaped by ethnic and religious considerations. Saudi Arabia unified under Ibn Saud's leadership by 1932. France received mandates over Syria and Lebanon, while Britain assumed responsibility for Iraq, Transjordan, and Palestine. Each new state reflected distinct identities: Iraq emerged as primarily Arab with significant Kurdish minorities, Lebanon was designated as a Christian-majority state, and Syria was established as an Arab nation.
The 1920 Treaty of San Remo designated Ottoman Palestine, including present-day Jordan, as a national home for the Jewish people under British mandate. However, in 1922, Britain separated Transjordan (now Jordan) from Palestine, giving it to the Hashemite dynasty and reducing the area intended for Jewish settlement by 78%. Jewish immigration increased dramatically in the 1930s as Europeans fled Nazi persecution, leading to tensions with the local Arab population who saw their hopes for independence threatened. The British response – severely restricting Jewish immigration through the 1939 White Paper – came precisely when Jews most desperately needed refuge from Nazi persecution.
Birth of a Jewish nation
After World War II and the Holocaust, international pressure for a Jewish state intensified, culminating in the 1947 UN Partition Plan and Israel's establishment in 1948. Like other new nations of the era, Israel's birth triggered significant population movements. Just as millions of Muslims had relocated from India to the newly created Pakistan, Israel's establishment led to profound demographic changes: approximately 700,000 Palestinians fled or were expelled during the 1948 war, while about 850,000 Jews were forced to leave Arab countries where they had lived for centuries, most finding refuge in Israel.
Israeli society today
These historical currents have shaped modern Israeli society in unexpected ways. While most American Jews descend from Eastern European immigrants, Israel's Jewish population shows remarkable diversity. Recent studies reveal that about 44.9% of Israeli Jews have Mizrahi (Middle Eastern/North African) origins, 44.2% are Ashkenazi (European descent), 7.9% claim mixed heritage, and 3% are Ethiopian Jews. This demographic reality challenges simplistic narratives about Israeli Jews being "European colonizers." More than half of Israel's Jewish population traces their roots to the Middle East and North Africa.
Today's diverse Israeli society reflects the convergence of two great streams of Jewish history: the Jews who maintained a continuous presence in the Middle East and North Africa, and those who built flourishing communities in Europe before returning to their ancestral homeland.
To understand how these distinct communities developed while maintaining their shared identity, we must first trace the remarkable journey of Ashkenazi Jewry. Their story, perhaps one of history's most extraordinary examples of cultural preservation and demographic growth, begins in medieval Europe and reveals much about how Jewish communities adapted to new environments while maintaining their essential character.
Jews migrated to Eastern Europe from Central Europe, gradually, from the 13th to 16th centuries. At the time, the region was governed by the Polish-Lithuanian Commonwealth during a period of significant territorial expansion and economic development.
Polish rulers, notably Casimir the Great (1333-1370), actively encouraged Jewish settlement by granting protection and economic privileges. The 1264 Statute of Kalisz, which became the model for later Jewish charters throughout Poland-Lithuania, guaranteed Jews the freedom to trade, protection from local persecution, and relative autonomy in managing their internal affairs.
The political environment helped develop the unique Ashkenazi socio-economic niche and communal structure. Jews became integral to Poland's estate economy as traders, tax collectors, and craftsmen. They often served as middlemen between the noble landowners and peasant serfs, managing estates and developing the arendas system ( leasing of noble estates and economic enterprises to Jewish managers). This economic role, while sometimes precarious, provided the basis for community growth and stability.
The demographic expansion of this period was extraordinary. Historical records show the Jewish population in Eastern Europe grew from approximately 250,000-350,000 around 1650 to 750,000 by 1765 and reached an astounding 8.5 million by 1900 (including families who had emigrated to Western countries). This growth occurred despite periodic catastrophes such as the Chmielnicki massacres of 1648-1649.
Several factors contributed to this remarkable population increase. Jewish religious and cultural practices encouraged early marriage and childbearing, leading to high fertility rates. Additionally, Jews experienced better survival rates than surrounding populations. This increased survival rate can be attributed to various factors: religious practices that inadvertently promoted better hygiene, the presence of Jewish physicians in communities, widespread literacy and education, and strong communal welfare systems that supported the vulnerable. The relatively better urban sanitation in Jewish quarters and dietary laws that may have provided some protection against disease also played important roles in this demographic success.
The Jews who migrated to Eastern Europe came from communities in Central Europe and belonged to a network of Jewish communities that spanned the European continent in the Middle Ages. These communities had developed in the Rhine Valley during the early medieval period, establishing important centers of Jewish learning in cities like Mainz, Worms, and Speyer. These German Jewish communities, known collectively as Ashkenaz (the medieval Hebrew name for the German lands), developed distinct customs, religious traditions, and eventually their own language - Yiddish, a fusion of medieval German dialects with Hebrew and Aramaic elements. When conditions deteriorated in Western Europe, with Jews facing persecution and expulsions from England (1290), France (1394), and various German territories, many moved eastward into Poland-Lithuania, carrying with them their distinct Ashkenazi cultural heritage.
The communities developed distinctive institutions that reinforced their cohesion and survival. The kehilla (community council) system provided local governance and social services. The yeshiva system of religious academies preserved and developed Jewish learning. A network of Jewish courts administered Jewish law. This institutional framework, combined with the use of Yiddish as a common language, created a distinct and resilient Jewish society within the larger Polish-Lithuanian state.
This period also saw the emergence of distinctive Ashkenazi religious and cultural patterns that would have long-lasting effects. These included new legal interpretations adapted to northern European conditions, the development of Yiddish culture and literature, unique styles of Torah study, and new religious movements like Hasidism. The relative isolation from other Jewish communities led to the development of distinctive customs in everything from synagogue architecture to dietary laws to wedding ceremonies.
The origins of the early Jewish community in the Rhineland are somewhat difficult to trace with historical records alone. However, the available evidence suggests these communities can be traced back to Late Antiquity and the Roman era.
The earliest explicit documentary evidence for the presence of Jews in the Rhineland region dates to the 4th century CE. The Codex Theodosianus, a collection of Roman imperial laws, referenced the existence of Jewish communities living in cities like Cologne and Trier during this period. This indicates these Jewish settlements may have roots tracing back to the Jewish populations of the Roman Empire. Archaeological evidence supports this timeline, with discoveries including a Roman-era synagogue in Cologne and Jewish artifacts from this period found throughout the region.
There is also evidence of Jewish migration to the Rhineland from other parts of Europe in the medieval period. For example, historical chronicles mention the migration of the Kalonymus family from Italy to the city of Mainz in the 10th century CE. This family would go on to produce several important Jewish scholars and leaders in medieval Ashkenaz. Their story suggests a pattern of intermittent movement of Jews into the region over the centuries, often bringing with them religious and cultural traditions from older Jewish centers in Italy and the Mediterranean.
These medieval Jewish communities maintained strong connections with their origins in the Land of Israel through religious practice, historical memory, and ongoing communication with Jewish communities across Europe and the Middle East. The Rhineland communities developed into major centers of Jewish learning, producing influential religious texts and commentaries that are still studied today. The most famous of these scholars was Rashi (Rabbi Shlomo Yitzhaki, 1040-1105), whose biblical and Talmudic commentaries became fundamental texts of Jewish learning and remain so to this day.
Ancient Jewish communities: From Babylon to Rome
While the Ashkenazi story unfolded in Europe, an older Jewish world had flourished continuously in the lands of its origins. The scale of this ancient Jewish life is staggering: at the height of the Roman Empire, Jews numbered between 4 to 8 million people – roughly 10% of the empire's total population. This remarkable diaspora began centuries before Rome, with the Babylonian conquest of Jerusalem in 586 BCE.
When the Babylonian king Nebuchadnezzar exiled much of the Jewish population to what is now southern Iraq, he unknowingly initiated one of history's most enduring cultural dispersions. Rather than disappearing, the exiled community flourished. Even when the Persian emperor Cyrus offered Jews the chance to return to Jerusalem fifty years later, many chose to remain in Babylonia, establishing what would become one of history's most influential Jewish centers.
Under successive empires – Persian, Greek, and Roman – Jewish communities spread across the ancient world. The biblical Book of Esther describes Jews living throughout Persia's 127 provinces, while archaeological discoveries like the Elephantine papyri document Jewish military colonies serving in southern Egypt. During the Hellenistic period, Greek cities became home to thriving Jewish communities with Alexandria emerging as the diaspora's crown jewel – its Jewish population reaching 40% of the city total, with a Great Synagogue renowned throughout the Mediterranean.
These communities developed distinct traditions reflecting their unique environments while maintaining their essential Jewish character. In Iraq, Jews traced their lineage to the Babylonian exile and developed the Babylonian Talmud. Egypt's Jews, present since at least the 6th century BCE, maintained a unique Hellenistic-Jewish culture. In Yemen, Jewish traders established communities before the rise of Islam, while across North Africa, Jewish life flourished under Roman and Muslim rule.
Each community developed its own dialect and customs – Judeo-Arabic in most Arab lands, Judeo-Persian in Iran, and Ladino (Judeo-Spanish) among Sephardic Jews, the Jews of the Iberian Peninsula, who were expelled by Christian monarchs and found refuge in the Ottoman Empire. Until the mid-20th century, these communities were integral to Middle Eastern society: Iraqi Jews dominated international trade and banking, Moroccan Jews were celebrated for their craftsmanship, and Jewish physicians and diplomats served in Muslim royal courts.
Despite their geographic spread and cultural adaptations, these communities maintained strong connections with their origins in the Land of Israel, sending donations to the Temple while it stood and later supporting Jewish academies in Israel and Babylonia. Archaeological evidence – ancient synagogues, ritual baths, and inscriptions in Latin, Greek, and Hebrew – reveals the deep roots these communities established while maintaining their distinctive Jewish identity.
The DNA of Jewish history: From ancient faith to modern science
While historical records trace a continuous line from ancient Judah to modern Jews, genetic science provides compelling evidence of these ancient connections. Through DNA analysis, scientists can now trace population movements with unprecedented precision, revealing the biological links between today's Jewish communities and their ancestral homeland.
Two types of genetic markers tell this story with particular clarity: the Y-chromosome, passed from father to son, and mitochondrial DNA, inherited from mother to child. One striking example is the Cohen Modal Haplotype – a distinct Y-chromosome pattern found frequently among Jewish men, identified as Kohanim (descendants of the ancient priesthood) but rarely in non-Jewish populations.
When scientists analyze genetic patterns among Jewish populations worldwide, they find that Jewish communities – whether Ashkenazi, Sephardic, or Mizrahi – share more DNA than their non-Jewish neighbors. The discovery of shared "identity by descent" segments – long stretches of identical DNA indicating common ancestry – suggests these communities maintained significant endogamy (marriage within the community) for centuries.
The genetic record also illuminates the complex story of Jewish migrations. Ashkenazi Jewish DNA shows both Middle Eastern and European ancestry, with the European influence appearing mainly through maternal lines – suggesting that Jewish men who migrated to Europe sometimes married local women who embraced Judaism. Mizrahi Jews, who remained in the Middle East and North Africa, show the strongest genetic links to the ancient Levant (the historical region in the Eastern Mediterranean that includes modern-day Israel, Jordan, Lebanon, Syria, and parts of Turkey) while Sephardic Jews display patterns between these two groups.
Most compelling is the discovery that Jewish populations worldwide share specific genetic signatures with other peoples from the Levant region – the area including ancient Judah. Modern Lebanese, Samaritans and some Syrian populations share some of these genetic patterns, indicating common ancient ancestry. This convergence of genetic evidence with historical records and archaeological findings provides powerful scientific confirmation of Jewish origins in the ancient Near East.
The Jewish story in stone, scripture, and science
The evidence for Jewish origins in ancient Judea emerges from three converging lines: archaeological discoveries revealing a distinctive culture in the Judean highlands, historical records tracing an unbroken chain of cultural transmission across continents, and genetic evidence confirming biological connections between modern Jewish communities and their ancient Levantine roots.
This convergence tells a remarkable story of continuity through change. While Jewish communities adapted to new homes – from Baghdad to Barcelona, from Yemen to the Rhine Valley – they maintained profound links to their origins. Archaeological remains, ancient texts, and DNA analysis all point to the same conclusion: a people who began their journey in the hills of Judea and maintained their distinctive identity through millennia of dispersion.
But this history speaks to more than just Jewish origins. It offers crucial insights into fundamental questions about human civilization: How do cultures survive across millennia? How do communities preserve their identity through exile? The Jewish experience presents a unique case study in cultural resilience, demonstrating how a group of people can maintain distinct traditions while engaging in cultural exchange, preserve core identity while adapting to new environments, and sustain biological continuity while welcoming newcomers.
In an age when questions of identity, migration, and cultural preservation have taken on new urgency, this history offers valuable perspectives. The Jewish story reminds us that human identity is resilient and adaptable, and capable of maintaining continuity across vast distances and time while embracing change. It stands as a testament to the remarkable capacity of human communities to preserve their essential character while continually renewing themselves in response to new circumstances.
Sources:
Atzmon, G., Hao, L., Pe’er, I., Velez, C., Pearlman, A., Palamara, P. F., . . . Ostrer, H. (2010). Abraham’s children in the genome era: major Jewish diaspora populations comprise distinct genetic clusters with shared Middle Eastern ancestry. The American Journal of Human Genetics, 86(6), 850–859.
Behar, D. M., Yunusbayev, B., Metspalu, M., Metspalu, E., Rosset, S., Parik, J., . . . Villems, R. (2010). The genome-wide structure of the Jewish people. Nature, 466(7303), 238–242.
Behar, D. M., Metspalu, M., Baran, Y., Kopelman, N. M., Yunusbayev, B., Gladstein, A., . . . Skorecki, K. (2013). No evidence from genome-wide data of a Khazar origin for the Ashkenazi Jews. Human Biology, 85(6), 859–900.
Bray, S. M., Mulle, J. G., Dodd, A. F., Pulver, A. E., Wooding, S., & Warren, S. T. (2010). Signatures of founder effects, admixture, and selection in the Ashkenazi Jewish population. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, 107(37), 16222–16227.
Campbell, C. L., Palamara, P. F., Dubrovsky, M., Botigué, L. R., Fellous, M., Atzmon, G., . . . Ostrer, H. (2012). North African Jewish and non-Jewish populations form distinctive, orthogonal clusters. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, 109(34), 13865–13870.
Costa, M. D., Pereira, J. B., Pala, M., Fernandes, V., Olivieri, A., Achilli, A., . . . Richards, M. B. (2013). A substantial prehistoric European ancestry amongst Ashkenazi maternal lineages. Nature Communications, 4, 2543.
DellaPergola, Sergio. "Notes toward a Demographic History of the Jews." Genealogy 8, no. 1 (2024): 1-29.
Guha, S., Rosenfeld, J., Malhotra, R., Pirinen, M., Myers, C., Peltonen, L., . . . Price, A. L. (2012). Implications for health and disease in the genetic signature of the Ashkenazi Jewish population. Genome Biology, 13(1), R2.
Hackett, Conrad and Jacob Ausubel. "Measuring the Size of the U.S. Jewish Population: New Estimates from a Pew Research Center Survey of Jewish Americans." Journal of Religion and Demography 8 (2021): 89-100.
Kopelman, N. M., Stone, L., Wang, C., Gefel, D., Feldman, M. W., Hillel, J., . . . Rosenberg, N. A. (2009). Genomic microsatellites identify shared Jewish ancestry intermediate between Middle Eastern and European populations. BMC Genetics, 10, 80.
Lederhendler, Eli. American Jewry: A New History. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 2016.
Lewin-Epstein, Noah and Yinon Cohen. "Ethnic Origin and Identity in the Jewish Population of Israel." Journal of Ethnic and Migration Studies 45, no. 11 (2019): 2118-2137.
Ostrer, H. (2001). A genetic profile of contemporary Jewish populations. Nature Reviews Genetics, 2(11), 891–898.
Ostrer, H., & Skorecki, K. (2013). The population genetics of the Jewish people. Human Genetics, 132(1), 119–127.
Tofanelli, S., Taglioli, L., Bertoncini, S., Francalacci, P., Klyosov, A., & Pagani, L. (2014). Mitochondrial and Y chromosome haplotype motifs as diagnostic markers of Jewish ancestry: a reconsideration. Frontiers in Genetics, 5, 384.
Ukeles, Jacob B. "Jewish Community Population Studies: Where Do We Go From Here?" Contemporary Jewry 36 (2016): 395-399.
Elon Gilad is an Israeli author, journalist, and linguist. His work focuses on uncovering the historical roots of contemporary issues, particularly in current affairs, Jewish history, and the Hebrew language. Gilad is the author of "The Secret History of Judaism." His analytical pieces draw on his diverse background to provide unique insights into today's complex issues, explaining current situations through the lens of historical development.